“…a little balm, and a little honey, spices, and myrrh, nuts, and almonds…”
— Genesis 43:11, KJV
Homemade Vanilla Extract is an easy, robust way to flavor your cooking. I am definitely that person who doesn’t even measure vanilla, ever. I just add a generous dunk whenever it is listed in the recipe. Too much always makes it better.
I remember as a kid wondering why we used Imitation Vanilla Extract. Why is it imitation, and what is wrong with the real stuff?
When you are busy and on a budget, it might feel like making it yourself is too much work for a small return. However, there are multiple reasons to do this: 1. It is literally as easy as pouring water – no skills required; 2. It is made with whole ingredients; and 3. Even though the vanilla beans seem pricy, they last you forever. (And by forever, I literally mean forever – I have not bought new vanilla beans in over five years since your spirit lasts a long, long time on the shelf.)
The last time I bought beans was 2018 and I am still using them. I don’t split mine; I wait for the booze to soak through and make them fall apart in the bottle. It happens very slowly.
Making your own ingredients sounds intimidating, but trust me, it is not. Vanilla Extract is one of those things that you can make on a continuous basis, never running out. I use a three-bottle system that has served me well over the years.
In my 3-bottle system, I have 2 full sized bottles (the size your spirit comes in) full of vanilla extract, and 1 smallish flip-top bottle that is for everyday use in my recipes. The two younger bottles are weaker, as I keep emptying them into my “everyday use” bottle and topping them off with straight spirit.

Cookies or cake made with homemade vanilla extract are so much better, and in my opinion, you can’t really have too much of it!
A beautiful and robust homemade vanilla, you can use it in any recipe that calls for vanilla extract.
TIPS:
- New to cooking from scratch? Never miss a recipe here.
- Initially, you will have to wait a few weeks for your vanilla to first become strong enough to use. After that, you should have continuous vanilla as long as you keep adding the ingredients to the last bottle.
- You will see other recipes online for extracting the flavor out of the vanilla beans using an Instant Pot and then discarding the beans. You can absolutely make a delicious vanilla extract that way, but it is more expensive, and you will have to do it more often. This recipe is a no-cook method.
- You can also use Bourbon for a different flavor.
FAQ:
VANILLA EXTRACT INGREDIENTS:
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 16 oz Whole Vanilla Beans (about 2 packages)
- 3 bottles of Vodka, Rum, or Spiced Rum
TOOLS:
- Small narrow-neck bottle with a flip top lid
- Funnel, or a really good eye and steady hand
HOW TO MAKE HOMEMADE VANILLA EXTRACT:

- Add 3-4 Vanilla beans to the small empty bottle. This will be your bottle of vanilla extract for everyday use.
- Using the funnel, pour Vodka, Rum, or Spiced Rum over the vanilla beans until the bottle is full. (Leave a space for the lid to close.)
- Store in a dark cabinet for 3-4 weeks, or until it darkens. It will become the rich, dark color of vanilla extract within a month.
- Number the other two bottles of your spirit, so you know which one to pull from first when you refill your small bottle.
- Divide remaining Vanilla Beans between the two bottles. (Plan on using 5-6 beans in each bottle, since they are bigger than your small everyday use bottle.) Put these bottles into a dark cabinet as well and allow the Vanilla to darken your spirit.
- As you run out of Vanilla in your small bottle, refill it from the next bottle, and then refill that one from the youngest and weakest bottle. The youngest bottle of Vanilla Extract should always be the one with the least amount of liquid in it.
- As you use your last bottle of Vanilla Extract, top it off with your spirit. It will infuse as you use your everyday Vanilla Extract. By the time this bottle is ready for use, it will be dark and robust like the others.
- With this system, you can keep your Vanilla going for a very, very long time before you have to buy new Vanilla Beans.
- If you notice that your Vanilla is weakening in strength or is beginning to lighten in color, you can add more beans to all 3 bottles. (This should not happen for quite a long time, however.)
Small bottles of homemade vanilla extract are amazing gifts to give your family members who enjoy baking. You have to start early, though, because it takes time for the vanilla to infuse into the liquor.
Follow me for more kitchen hacks and staples like this easier-than-pie homemade Vanilla extract.
YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY…
- How Am I Supposed to Accomplish the Fantastic If I Can’t Even Do the Mundane?
- All of It, for Now
- August Still Wants to Stay Up
- Canning Spaghetti Sauce
- Vodka Lemon Cleaner for Bleach-Free Disinfecting

One Comment