Home » Blog » Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream Recipe

Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream Recipe

Vanilla ice cream is a classic. This homemade creamy custard-based vanilla ice cream recipe is surprisingly easy to make, and healthier than the conventional summer ice cream cone. I am excited to take my ice cream maker for a spin and experiment with new add-in items, flavors and techniques to share. Come on in!

Two scoops of vanilla ice cream in a yellow bowl on a bamboo tray.

“There was ice cream, actually two dishes of it, pink and white, and cake and fruit and distracting French bonbons and, in the middle of the table, four great bouquets of hot house flowers.”

— Little Women, Louisa May Alcott, Chapter Two

This letter may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Who can forget the Barbershop Quartet in the Music Man singing over and over, “ice cream, Ice Cream, ICE CREAM, IIIICE CREEEEEEEEEAM!” It is one of my favorite musicals, and I could not help but remember this scene as I was making homemade vanilla ice cream. (My love languages in order are ice cream and movie quotes, so it works.)

(I feel like it might be against the law to begin an ice cream post without saying the obligatory “I Scream, You Scream, We All Scream for Ice Cream,” but here I am!)

Vanilla ice cream is a classic. This homemade creamy custard-based vanilla ice cream recipe is surprisingly easy to make, and healthier than the conventional summer ice cream cone. I am excited to take my ice cream maker for a spin and experiment with new add-in items, flavors and techniques to share. Come on in!

Who doesn’t have memories of chasing an ice cream truck, racing the sun to finish an ice cream cone before it melted, or watching their grandfather turn the hand crank on an old fashioned ice cream maker? (Or, breaking up the bag of rock salt in the driveway in preparation for making ice cream!) Ice cream has so much summer delight, I just had to try making it.

When you have a busy schedule, ice cream in any form seems like such a luxury. But, this recipe is easy and is made from whole, simple ingredients. It is such an extra sweet treat for your whole family. Vanilla is my flavor of choice to get started. Once I have mastered Vanilla, I can use it as my base to create different ice cream flavors.

Whenever you happen to have extra cream on hand, this is an extra special treat to churn up and stick back into the freezer to save for a hot summer day. You can prep enough to last, or you can make it one serving at a time, whichever fits your life the best.

My favorite ice cream flavor has always been mint chocolate chip. I am not a big fan of tons of toppings. I want to taste the actual ice cream, not just the sugar in the toppings. However, if I had to choose a favorite topping, I would pick a chocolate syrup. But, I don’t think I have tried a flavor that I did not like at all. Ice cream is always a win.

Two scoops of homemade vanilla ice cream in a yellow bowl.

EQUIPMENT

I bought the Kitchen Aid Ice Cream Attachment a while back, and I have been excited to experiment with flavors and types. Tutorials on YouTube are abundant about how to make delicious icy fruit and milk blends in the Vitamix that are a lot LIKE ice cream (and we will do that in the video for sure!), but I wanted to make REAL ice cream. While I can’t resist trying the Vitamix way, I want to level up my ice cream game. (Watch this week’s video below to watch me make blender “ice cream” in the Vitamix!)

I am excited to try making Sorbet, Sherbet, Frozen Yogurt (FroYo), Italian Ice, and Gelato. I can’t wait to try more flavor ideas. Stay Tuned for future blog posts on these topics!

Two scoops of homemade vanilla ice cream in a yellow bowl.

TIPS

  • Don’t forget to chill you ice cream bowl the day before.
  • Temper your egg yolks to avoid cooking them solid before you mix them in.
  • Make sure the ice cream maker churns long enough.
  • Use full fat milk and cream. Low fat options will not produce that cold, creamy consistency.
  • If you are going to store the ice cream in the freezer for a period of time before eating it, add 1 Tbs. of vodka to the ice cream maker while it is churning. Since vodka does not freeze, it will keep the ice cream scoopable when you retrieve it.
Two scoops of homemade vanilla ice cream in a yellow bowl.

FAQ:

How do I make ice cream step by step?

The big-picture process is: stir cream and sugar ingredients over low heat until fully coagulated. Then, add remaining ingredients. After it has cooled, slowly pour the mixture into the ice cream maker. Churn 20-25 minutes. The details will vary slightly depending on what recipe you are using and what ice cream maker you have.

What not to do while making ice cream?

Make sure your ice cream maker and all ingredients are fully chilled when you begin churning. Use full fat ingredients.

Does homemade ice cream need to be cooked?

It depends on the type of ice cream. Many ice cream recipes have a custard base, which requires cooking over the stove. Others, such as frozen yogurt, are not cooked. There are also many vitamix recipes that require blending of chilled ingredients to achieve their ice cream like texture, but require no cooking.

What are the 3 most important ingredients of ice cream?

The 3 most important ingredients of ice cream are milk, cream, and sugar. Without those ingredients, it just would not be ice cream at all!

Can you make ice cream without an ice cream maker?

There are variations of ice cream products that can be made with a blender. However, most true ice cream recipes require an ice cream base that is churned, which is much easier with a an ice cream maker.

Is Homemade Ice Cream Healthier than Store Bought?

Homemade Ice Cream often calls for just the base ingredients: Milk, Cream, Sugar, Eggs, and your add-in items and flavors. However, store bought ice cream often has chemical flavors, high fructose corn syrup, and sweetened condensed milk. (I avoid all three of these items in home cooking!) Homemade is often healthier than store bought because it was made from fresh ingredients and is made from whole foods. (The only thing that would make it better is farm fresh milk and eggs!)

Two scoops of homemade vanilla ice cream in a yellow bowl.

INGREDIENTS

  • Milk
  • Heavy Cream
  • Turbinado Sugar
  • Egg Yolk
  • Vanilla Extract (I make my own from Vanilla Beans)

TOOLS

How To Make Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream:

  • Gather two medium sized sauce pans and spoons for stirring. As you follow this recipe, you will simmer both sauce pans simultaneously on the range top.
  • Add egg yolks, sugar, and vanilla to the first sauce pan. Simmer over low to medium heat while stirring continuously. (You do not want the egg to cook solid, but remain a thick liquid as it heats.)
  • While the egg mixture is heating up, simmer cream, milk, and vanilla over low to medium heat. It should be bubbling and steaming, but not boiling.
  • Maintain both sauce pans by stirring continuously until they are bubbling but not boiling.
  • To combine, slowly pour the hot milk and cream mixture into the sauce pan with the egg mixture while whisking briskly.
  • Once combined into the same sauce pan, pour the mixture into a refrigerator safe container and chill overnight for 24 hours. (Put your ice cream attachment into the freezer at the same time so both are chilled when you make the ice cream.)
  • The next day, begin your ice cream maker at a slow speed. You want the mixer to be turning before you pour the ice cream mixture into the bowl. If you pour the ice cream liquid while stationery, it may freeze too quickly and the paddle will not churn.
  • While the ice cream maker is turning, slowly pour the ice cream liquid into the bowl.
  • Allow the ice cream paddle to turn for 20 to 30 minutes. You will see the liquid begin to thicken and form ice cream!
  • Stop the ice cream maker and scrape the ice cream from the paddle and bowl into a freezer container. It will be creamy and delicious straight from the ice cream machine, but it will keep in the freezer for a month or so. Enjoy!
Two scoops of vanilla ice cream in a yellow bowl on a bamboo tray.

Vanilla Ice Cream

This is a creamy, delicious, and EASY homemade ice cream recipe!
Cook Time 30 minutes
Churning Time 30 minutes
Total Time 1 hour
Servings 6

Equipment

  • KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment
  • 2 Sauce Pans
  • 2 Spoons for stirring
  • 1 Spatula

Ingredients
  

  • 6 Egg Yolks
  • 2/3 C. Turbinado Sugar
  • 1 Tbsp. Vanilla Extract
  • 2 1/2 C. Heavy Cream
  • 1 1/2 C. Whole Milk

Instructions
 

  • Gather two medium sized sauce pans and spoons for stirring. As you follow this recipe, you will simmer both sauce pans simultaneously on the range top.
  • Add egg yolks, sugar, and vanilla to the first sauce pan. Simmer over low to medium heat while stirring continuously. (You do not want the egg to cook solid, but remain a thick liquid as it heats.)
  • While the egg mixture is heating up, simmer cream, milk, and vanilla over low to medium heat. It should be bubbling and steaming, but not boiling.
  • Maintain both sauce pans by stirring continuously until they are bubbling but not boiling.
  • To combine, slowly pour the hot milk and cream mixture into the sauce pan with the egg mixture while whisking briskly.
  • Once combined into the same sauce pan, pour the mixture into a refrigerator safe container and chill overnight for 24 hours. (Put your ice cream attachment into the freezer at the same time so both are chilled when you make the ice cream.)
  • The next day, begin your ice cream maker at a slow speed. You want the mixer to be turning before you pour the ice cream mixture into the bowl. If you pour the ice cream liquid while stationery, it may freeze too quickly and the paddle will not churn.
  • While the ice cream maker is turning, slowly pour the ice cream liquid into the bowl.
  • Allow the ice cream paddle to turn for 20 to 30 minutes. You will see the liquid begin to thicken and form ice cream!
  • Stop the ice cream maker and scrape the ice cream from the paddle and bowl into a freezer container. It will be creamy and delicious straight from the ice cream machine, but it will keep in the freezer for a month or so. Enjoy!

Notes

I used the Kitchen Aid Ice Cream attachment for this recipe. If you use a different type of ice cream maker, the same basic recipe concept will work. However, you will need to adjust the churning part of the recipe to the instructions provided with your ice cream maker.

If you liked this Homemade Ice Cream Recipe, you might also like:

  • Easy 2 Ingredient Skin Care – Many natural products, common household ingredients that you already have in your home, can replace high end skin products. Oils, clays, salt, juices, and basic dry baking ingredients can replace so many things. When I grocery shop, I rarely buy something that you can simply open and eat anymore, other than fruit. It is all individual ingredients that you have to process at home: flour, sugar, salt, beans, coffee, spices, etc.
  • 34 Ways to Summer Hygge + Classic Lemonade Recipe – Summer Hygge is the perfect time for a picnic, a cup of cold, sweet tea instead of rich mocha and hot chocolate. The increased sunlight and warmer weather after a winter season of rest is known for making us feel energized and happy — and it should. Try my oh-so-simple Classic Lemonade Recipe as you enjoy the bright summer days.
  • Why Won’t My Garden Grow? I wish I had a penny for every time I’ve asked “what is wrong with my garden.” Why won’t my garden grow? Unfortunately, experience is the best teacher. I’ve learned so much, and I still have yet to conquer the ever present squash vine borer. If you keep going, your garden will come around. Join me today as we troubleshoot things that can go wrong in the garden and learn from them.
  • Perfect Cinnamon Popovers are an easy and delicious treat that your family will love. Whip it up with a few simple ingredients that are already in your pantry. Stick them in the oven for a presto-changeo hot breakfast.
  • Summer Fika Break + Homestead Coffee Recipe – As I have been learning about homesteading, slow living, and being conscious about our health choices, I learned about something else that goes hand in hand with all of those things: Fika. The root of all of these things is to shed the cloak of “treadmill style” obligations, to slow down and look life in the eye, and to focus on work that is truly meaningful.

A Little Something For You

Letters from my little brick house with recipes and stories from daily life.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Similar Posts

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating