Home » Blog » All Natural Homemade Play Dough

All Natural Homemade Play Dough

Homemade Play Dough is an easy, all natural, non-toxic way to keep your littles occupied while you make dinner or take care of the house. It is completely edible and guilt-free to toss in the compost when it begins to dry out.

A row of edible play dough, red, yellow, light green, and blue, sits on a cutting board in front of a head of cabbage and carrots

“To plant seeds in—to make things grow—to see them come alive,” Mary faltered.

— The Secret Garden, Frances Hodgson Burnett, Chapter XII

This letter may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Jump to Recipe

Homemade Play Dough is an easy, all natural, non-toxic way to keep your littles occupied while you make dinner or take care of the house. It is completely edible and guilt-free to toss in the compost when it begins to dry out.

This is a twist on classic play dough. Without standard food colorings, fragrances, petroleum, or borax, homemade play dough is safe for your littles’ sensory play.

When you are busy, it might seem like a lot of work to make play dough. However, you can whip a plain version together with no food coloring for them to play with while sitting in the highchair or at the table while you work. If you color it, it will take slightly longer, but either way, the amount of time it takes is very short.

Creating playthings for your kids such as homemade play dough does not have to be super time consuming. You can put it together in just a minute or make it ahead of time and store it in airtight containers to pull out when you need it. It is very easy to just pop all the ingredients into the mixer with the dough hook and run it for about 5 minutes.

The kids are always thrilled to see fresh play dough available for them to roll out, punch, and make shapes with. It is one of the most classic sensory toys ever. It does not become a sticky mess, but adheres to itself while the kids are playing with it.

A fun, gentle toy, this homemade playdough recipe will become a staple in your household while the kids are little.

A row of edible play dough, red, yellow, light green, and blue, sits on a cutting board

PLAY DOUGH TIPS

  • Don’t overthink it. If it works into your schedule to make this, then try it. Otherwise, don’t feel like you must cram 600 extra things into your day.
  • Try a variety of natural food colorings for your play dough. Try boiling lemon peels, orange peels, spinach, or other colored foods to create a natural food coloring. The worst thing that can happen is that you didn’t get the color you wanted. Feel free to experiment! If you are using an edible item, the end product will be edible. (Note: some plants, such as rhubarb leaves, are not edible – so don’t assume that every part of every edible plant is edible. Make sure that you are using known edible food items, such as berries, fruits, and vegetables, not just any leaf or plant that you happen to have. Babies and toddlers put everything in their mouths!)
  • This play dough stores well in airtight containers. However, you can make it ahead and save it, or you can whip it up right before using.
  • Don’t stress if it gets icky from being touched over and over, or if it dries out. It is cheap and easy to make more play dough.
  • Instead of making this recipe, consider letting the baby play with a small slice of bread dough, pie crust dough, or a piece of something you are working on. Restaurants bring pizza dough out to babies who are active, so why can’t we?
  • You can adjust the amount of “grit” in the dough by using a different grain of salt. If you use kosher salt or celtic sea salt, it will have a grittier texture. If you use regular table salt, it will be smooth. For children looking for different sensory textures, this is an easy substitution.
A row of edible play dough, red, yellow, light green, and blue, sits on a cutting board in front of a head of cabbage and carrots

Play Dough FAQ

What are the main ingredients in homemade playdough?

The main ingredients are water, flour, salt, oil, and baking powder. If desired, you can add a color or a fragrance.

Can you make a soft playdough edible?

If you add baby powder, shaving cream, conditioner, glue, or experiment with oils, it will no longer be edible. These types of play dough might make a great soft, squishy, or stretchy texture, such as cloud dough or moon dough, it should be used by older children who are past the age of putting everything in their mouths.

What makes play dough fluffy?

Baking powder will help the play dough bind together and make a smooth, fluffy texture. You can also add cornstarch, cream of tartar, lemon juice, or other natural ingredients to adjust the texture. However, if you add baby powder or shaving cream (standard ingredients in fluffy dough or slime) it will no longer be edible.

A row of edible play dough, red, yellow, light green, and blue, sits stacked on a cutting board

INGREDIENTS

  • 2 C. Unbleached Flour
  • 2 C. Filtered Water (I filter mine with a Berkey.)
  • 1 C. Salt
  • 2 T. Coconut Oil
  • 2 Tbsp. Baking Powder (aluminum free), or 1Tbsp. each Baking Soda and Cream of Tartar
  • Beets, Blue Spirilina, Orange Peels, Lemon Peels, Turmeric, Spinach, Blueberries, and other natural ingredients to make different colors for the dye.

TOOLS

INSTRUCTIONS

  • Add beets and water to sauce pan to make red food coloring.
  • Heat up slowly, stirring constantly.
  • When the red color of the beets are fully incorporated into the water, remove from heat and allow it to cool. (If the color is too light, add more beets until it makes your perfect shade.)
  • Strain water and discard pulp. Remove 2 cups of the water for use in your recipe. Repeat for all the different colors you wish to try.
  • Add all ingredients to the stand mixer bowl with the dough hook: flour, colored water, salt, coconut oil, and baking powder. Begin on the lowest speed and let it run for 5-8 minutes. If necessary, use a spatula to scrape the ingredients down from the sides so they will be fully incorporated.
  • Remove from mixer when it forms a ball of dough. It will be ready to use as soon as it has formed.
  • Store play dough an airtight container when not in use. Discard when it has begun to dry out or becomes dirty.

All Natural Play Dough

Homemade Play Dough is an easy, all natural, non-toxic way to keep your littles occupied while you make dinner or take care of the house. It is completely edible and guilt-free to toss in the compost when it begins to dry out.
Prep Time15 minutes
Active Time10 minutes

Equipment

  • 1 Stand Mixer with Dough Hook (optional)
  • 1 Large mixing bowl (optional)
  • 1 Spoon for stirring
  • 1 Spatula
  • 1 Sauce Pan

Materials

  • 2 C. Flour
  • 1 C. Water
  • 2 Tbsp. Coconut Oil
  • 2 Tbsp. Baking Powder
  • 1 C. Salt
  • Beets, Blue Spirulina, Spinach, Orange Peels, Lemon Peels, Turmeric, Coffee Grounds, Blueberries, or other colored items to make the dyes. (quantities variable).

Instructions

  • To make red food coloring, add beets and water to sauce pan.
  • Heat up slowly, stirring constantly.
  • Increase the amount of beets until you achieve the color you wanted. When the beets are fully incorporated into the water, remove from heat and allow it to cool. (If the color is too light, add more beets until it makes your perfect shade.)
  • Strain water and discard pulp. Remove 2 cups of the water for use in your recipe. Repeat for all the different colors you wish to try.
  • Add all ingredients to the stand mixer bowl with the dough hook: flour, colored water, salt, coconut oil, and baking powder. Begin on the lowest speed and let it run for 5-8 minutes. If necessary, use a spatula to scrape the ingredients down from the sides so they will be fully incorporated.
  • Remove from mixer when it forms a ball of dough. It will be ready to use as soon as it has formed.
  • Store in an airtight container when not in use. Discard when it has begun to dry out or becomes dirty.
a child's hand rolling out light blue play dough

YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY…

  • When to Plant a Fall Garden â€“ If you’re not planting a fall garden, you are really missing out! A variety of edible plants grow very well in cooler conditions. By September, many of the summer pests have died back. As a bonus, you don’t have to water your garden as often because the soil retains moisture on its own in the fall.
  • Easy Homemade Granola RecipeA beautiful, crunchy texture with a hint of maple, vanilla, and toasted nuts.
  • DIY Dish Detergent â€“ This all natural dish detergent recipe is perfect for soaking those larger pots with stuck-on food, or hand washing a load of dishes in the kitchen sink.
  • Crunchy Dill Pickle â€“ This crunchy dill pickle recipe is crisp, tart, easy to make, and everything a pickle should be. If you have an abundance of fresh cucumbers and dill, this is a great recipe to keep in your back pocket.
  • 101 Screen Free Activities for Kids – With handheld devices on the rise and literacy on the decline, I often wonder what the influx of screens is doing to our children. I constantly wonder, “are their brains growing at the proper rate? Are they over stimulated? Are they learning what they need to learn? How do we fix this without living in a cave and disengaging from the world? Is it even possible to have screen free kids?”

A Little Something For You

Letters from my little brick house with recipes and stories from daily life.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating