“In the room on the left a long supper-table was seen, set forth with great pitchers of new milk, piles of brown and white bread, and perfect stacks of the shiny gingerbread so dear to boyish souls.”
— Little Men, Louisa May Alcott, Chapter I
This letter may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Jump to RecipeThere’s nothing better than a light, fluffy, soft sourdough bread. A beautiful thin crust on the outside and light on the inside, perfect for sandwiches.

This transforms my normal rustic sourdough bread into a light, fluffy bread more suitable for sandwiches and French toast.
When you have a busy schedule, fiddling with your bread recipe to get it just right sounds like an extra job. (Trust me, I’ve made my share of ugly bread!) But, once you get it the way you like it, that recipe is golden.
Bread baking can become second nature because it is relaxing and, with some creativity, incorporate into your routine. You can prep all of your bread for one week on Saturday evening, pop them in the refrigerator, and bake as needed in order to streamline. The refrigeration will keep the dough from overproofing since it slows down the fermentation process.
You might have beginner’s luck and make beautiful bread loaves at the first try. But for me, that was not the case. I tried all kinds of bread recipes. These heavy, dense loaves became croutons, crackers, even bird food, because who wants a sandwich you can’t bite into? (I know, right? Facepalm.) But, it was not wasted. Those ugly loaves were the price of education. Experience is the best teacher, so roll your sleeves up and just do it ugly and troubleshoot until you get something that you like.
I was used to heavy, dense homemade bread, and I was way more excited than anyone should be about bread when I saw these light, fluffy loaves for the first time – perfect for toast, sandwiches, and all kinds of practical things. I am still thrilled every time I see the bread rising and creating a beautiful golden crust. It goes so well with soup or sandwiches. But, having a soft sandwich recipe makes all the difference.
A light and airy bread, you can eat a slice with butter, make a sandwich, French toast, or a delicious grilled cheese sandwich.

SOFT SOURDOUGH BREAD TIPS:
- If you are new to sourdough, do not be afraid! Most of the time is spent waiting. The wild yeast does all of the magic for you. Follow the process and let it do its thing.
- A new, fresh sourdough starter will be ready within a week in order to let the wild yeast develop. To make a fresh starter, mix flour and water together in a jar. Let it sit at room temperature. Every day, scoop out some and replace what you removed with fresh flour and water. The starter that you removed is called discard. But, don’t throw it away! This discard can be used for pancakes and biscuits and things.
- The difference between a good soft bread and a regular crusty sourdough bread is what you feed it in order to get the perfect texture you are looking for. With a crusty bread, the microbes are feeding exclusively on the new flour that you mix in. With a soft bread, you have to feed it sugar and oil in order to to make it light. This makes a big difference in the density of the bread.
- During the winter there is nothing like a piece of homemade bread with butter and a bowl of soup.

SOURDOUGH FAQ:
Why is my sourdough bread crumbly?
A bread that is too crumbly has too much flour in it or too little liquid. Try increasing your liquid slightly and hydrating your dough. You want it to be a wet dough, not too sticky, and thicker than a batter. You should be able to shape it with your hands. Too much moisture is just as bad as too little – if it is crumbly or overly sticky, it is not the right texture.
What is open crumb?
Open crumb is the beautiful, light, bubbly interior that is the pride of every sourdough baker. You can achieve open crumb by making sure your flour is adequately hydrated. A closed crumb loaf will be dense, heavy, and will not cut well.
How do I make my Sourdough bread softer?
Sourdough bread is made softer by feeding the cultures with any/all of the following: milk, plain yogurt, buttermilk, whey, butter, sugar, or even eggs. This recipe calls for sugar, butter, and milk or whey in order to give the bread that beautiful open crumb texture.
Why is my Sourdough bread so hard?
If your sourdough bread is hard, it is probably underproofed, meaning that it did not rise long enough.
SOFT SOURDOUGH BREAD INGREDIENTS:
- 1/4 C. Turbinado Sugar
- 1 C. Sourdough Discard
- 1/2 C. Olive Oil
- 1 C. Milk or Whey leftover from making Yogurt
- 2 eggs
- 5 C. Unbleached All Purpose Flour
- 1 Tbsp. Sea Salt
TOOLS:
- Stand mixer with dough hook
- Spatula
- Loaf Pan (The two loaf pans I have do not match each other. One is a standard glass loaf pan and the other one is vintage.)
- My favorite Flour Sack Towels (Simpli-Magic)
HOW TO MAKE SOFT SOURDOUGH BREAD:
- Add all ingredients to stand mixer a little at a time. Let it rotate as you add new ingredients.
- Allow mixer to rotate until the ingredients are fully incorporated. It should be a smooth ball.
- Remove bowl from mixer and cover with a towel to rise overnight.
- When the dough has at least doubled, remove from the bowl.
- Cut dough in half and shape loaves.
- Add to greased loaf pans.
- Let it rise a second time at room temperature. (Allow 2-4 hours for the second rise.)
- While the bread is rising, preheat oven to 350 F.
- Bake at 350 for 1 hour.

Soft Sourdough Bread
Equipment
- Spatula
- Stand Mixer with Dough Hook
- Loaf Pans
- My Favorite Flour Sack Towels
Ingredients
- 1/4 C. Turbinado Sugar
- 1 C. Sourdough Discard
- 1/2 C. Oil
- 1 C. Milk or Whey
- 2 eggs
- 5 C. Unbleached All Purpose Flour
- 1 Tbsp. Salt
Instructions
- Add all ingredients to stand mixer a little at a time. Let it rotate as you add new ingredients.
- Allow mixer to rotate until the ingredients are fully incorporated. It should be a smooth ball.
- Remove bowl from mixer and cover with a towel to rise overnight.
- When the dough has at least doubled, remove from the bowl.
- Cut dough in half and shape loaves.
- Add to greased loaf pans.
- Let it rise a second time at room temperature. (Allow 2-4 hours for the second rise.)
- While the bread is rising, preheat oven to 350 F.
- Bake at 350 for 1 hour.
HOW TO SERVE:
Try this delicious soft bread as a grilled cheese sandwich, french toast, panini, garlic bread, or all kinds of things! It is airy and light.

YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY…
- Pressure Canned Soup – This home canned soup is a marriage between slow food and fast food. It is one of the closest things you will get to a home cooked meal that you can prepare in less than 10 minutes before dinner. This hack will save you tons of time.
- Homemade Sourdough Bread – I began my foray into fresh sourdough bread about five years ago. I have not looked back! I have made many beautiful and ugly sourdough of all types – multigrain, gluten-free, porridge bread, focaccia, pizza crust, pie crust, and so many other things. The process has taught me how to make a good crumb with wild yeast, and I am still learning!
- Sourdough Lemon Blackberry Bundt Cake – This moist, sweet, fruit laden sourdough bundt cake is easy to make. A beautiful glaze on the outside with a delectable interior full of lemon and berries.
- Pickled Peppers with Dill – Pop a jar of homemade pickled peppers to accent main dishes, add to soup, salsa, or pico de gallo. Delicious! This easy recipe, based on my crunchy dill pickle recipe, will preserve peppers for your pantry.
- One Pot Spaghetti – Spaghetti is already a very easy dish. However, this recipe is hands free, does not require you to babysit it, and there are fewer dishes to wash afterwards.

One Comment